Stephen Brobeck of CFA Questions $13.7B Realtor Commission Damages

Realtor Commissions Lawsuit

Real Estate Commissions | MLS Lawsuit | Introduction

Stephen Brobeck, Senior Fellow at The Consumer Federation of America, has advanced two seminal studies elucidating the negligible economic repercussions of substantially modifying commission structures, exposing the delusion of damages. Moreover, Brobeck endorses the measures taken by The National Association of Realtors concerning The Clear Co-Op policy and pocket listings.

Unraveling the Web of Misinformation: Understanding the Manipulation Tactics of Proptech Entities in the Residential Real Estate Sector

The residential real estate sector is facing a massive misinformation campaign. A flurry of superficially conceived allegations — spearheaded by discount and proptech real estate entities and pro-proptech online platforms, reiterated in class-action litigations — has sown widespread consumer perplexity.

Fortuitously, consumers can find a beacon of lucidity in the form of The Consumer Federation of America. Established in 1968, this non-profit consumer advocacy organization holds considerable sway, including demonstrable influence within the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Department of Justice (DOJ).

Stephen Brobeck’s Insightful Rebuttal to the Quest for Decoupled Commissions: A Glimpse into the Real Impacts on Consumers and Real Estate Brokers

In a press release aptly titled “CFA Predicts Impact on Consumers and Real Estate Brokers If Courts Require Uncoupled Commissions,” Stephen Brobeck elucidates the ineffectiveness of the Plaintiff’s quest to decouple commissions, resulting in buyers paying real estate commissions direct. He contends it lacks substantial influence on transaction cost dynamics, arguing, “These lenders will understand that to afford a new home, many buyers will need these fees to be included in their mortgage. Lenders will also know that these fees are currently largely or wholly included in the sale price, so the size of loans will not change appreciably.” He further expounds, “Many sellers will think they benefit by being charged commissions of 2.5-3 percent rather than 5-6 percent. Buyers will accept the fact that they now must pay their brokers 2.5-3 percent when brokers explain to them that this commission was previously included in the sale price.”

Stephen Brobeck’s Persuasive Commentary on the Limited Impact of Discount Brokers Amid Decoupled Commissions: A Testament to the Value of Personalized Service in Real Estate Transactions

Brobeck proceeds to downplay the influence of discount brokers if commissions are decoupled, contending, “Discounters will increase market share, but this share will remain relatively small because most consumers want effective personal service from a single agent. While technology can routinize much paperwork, most buyers and sellers will still desire the assistance of a professional who can guide and reassure them.”

Stephen Brobeck Advocates for Transparency in Real Estate: His Unveiling Critique of Pocket Listings and Commendation of NAR’s Clear Cooperation Policy

Addressing the Clear-Co-Operation Policy and Pocket Listings, Brobeck composed an analytical report titled “Why Pocket Listings of Homes For Sale Are Not In the Consumer Interest.” In this research, he posits, “CFA’s new analysis of pocket listings explains why pocket listings harm both home sellers and buyers and also threaten a free, efficient, and non-discriminatory housing market.” He adds, “CFA applauds the National Association of Realtors (NAR) for voting earlier this week to limit the use of anti-consumer pocket listings by real estate agents.”

Consumer Advocate Applauds the Consumer Federation of America: Spotlighting the Potential Consequences of Decoupling Commissions

Anthony Phillips, a consumer protection advocate, commends the painstaking efforts of The Consumer Federation of America in demystifying complex issues. Phillips conveys, “We endlessly appreciate The Consumer Federation of America’s commitment to disseminating impartial studies that benefit  consumers.” Additionally, Phillips underscores the potential adverse implications of decoupling commissions, such as obligating buyers to compensate their agents directly. He notes that this may have a profoundly negative impact on Federal Housing Administration loans, thereby disproportionately affecting low-income and minority communities. Further exacerbating the issue, Veteran Affairs loans prohibit buyers from covering commissions, leading to considerable uncertainty surrounding our veterans’ capacity to attain home ownership.

Stephen Brobeck’s Skepticism Towards Commission Decoupling Could Save Homeownership Paths for FHA and VA Buyers, Says Expert

In his closing remarks, Phillips asserted, “When a leading authority like Stephen Brobeck, who has championed consumer protection in the residential real estate market, questions the tangible benefits of decoupling for buyers and sellers, one could reasonably conclude that the present lawsuits will fail, preserving the current commission structure. In effect, Mr. Brobeck’s stance could single-handedly safeguard the pathways to homeownership for FHA and VA buyers.”

About Anthony Phillips

Carrying forward a rich legacy rooted in the heart of New England, Anthony Phillips upholds the revered family tradition of contributing to various fields like law, academia, business, politics, and consumer rights. Phillips’s illustrious heritage includes founders of the esteemed Phillips Andover and Phillips Exeter schools, Presidents of Harvard University, pioneers in the 19th-century abolition movement, and countless local and national legislators.

Scroll to Top